ICC Flags MCG Pitch, Hands Venue Official Demerit Point

Scott Boland claimed the big wicket of Harry Brook at MCG. Image: ESPN

In a rare move, the International Cricket Council (ICC) has rated the pitch at the Melbourne Cricket Ground (MCG) as “unsatisfactory” following the fourth Test of the 2025–26 Ashes series between Australia and England. As a result, the historic venue has been handed one demerit point under the ICC’s Pitch and Outfield Monitoring Process.

The decision comes after the Boxing Day Test concluded in an unusually short span of just two days, with England securing a four-wicket victory. The match saw 20 wickets fall on the opening day and 16 further dismissals on the second, and no batter managed to score a half-century — an exceedingly rare outcome in Test cricket.

What the Demerit Point Means?
Under ICC regulations, a pitch is assessed on balance between bat and ball. When a surface is judged as “unsatisfactory,” the venue earns one demerit point. Such points remain on record for five years. If a stadium accumulates six demerit points within that period, it faces a 12-month ban from hosting international matches.

At present, the single demerit point acts as a formal warning rather than something that will immediately stop the MCG from hosting future fixtures. However, it places the venue on notice regarding pitch preparation standards.

Criticism and Reactions
Match referee Jeff Crowe, who delivered the rating, said the surface favored bowlers excessively, contributing to the rapid conclusion of the Test match. Critics, including players and commentators, described the pitch conditions as not conducive to balanced competition, while some sporting analysts labeled the outcome disappointing for fans and the game’s spectacle.

Officials from Cricket Australia acknowledged the ICC’s verdict and emphasized that future pitch preparations will focus on providing a more equitable contest between bat and ball.

The spotlight now turns to future Test matches at the MCG, including the final Ashes match scheduled in Sydney, as stakeholders assess how to avoid repeat concerns about pitch quality at one of cricket’s most iconic stadiums.

crifosports/30December25/AZ